How to prepare for a job interview: Advice from an experienced recruiter

ld-favicon
Published on November 12, 2026
Written by Jenny Ennis

After more than 20 years working in recruitment, I’ve had countless conversations with hiring managers about what makes a successful job interview and, equally, what can let a candidate down.

One thing I’ve learnt is that having the right experience doesn’t always guarantee a job offer. Often, what makes the difference is how well you connect with the interviewer, communicate your strengths and demonstrate that you’re the right fit for the team.

In my experience recruiting Bookkeepers, Administration and Client Services professionals for accounting firms across Melbourne, hiring managers place considerable importance on cultural fit and the rapport they build with candidates during an interview.

So, how can you make sure you’re putting your best foot forward? Here are my practical tips to help you prepare, make a positive impression and stand out in your next job interview.

 

Do your homework before the interview

Preparation is one of the simplest ways to demonstrate genuine interest in an opportunity.

Before your interview, take time to research the organisation, understand the role and consider how your experience aligns with what they’re looking for. For candidates interviewing with accounting firms, this might mean understanding the firm’s client base, services, team structure and approach to client relationships.

It’s also worth revisiting your CV and preparing a few examples that demonstrate your strengths and achievements.

Ask yourself:

  • Why am I interested in this particular role and organisation?
  • What relevant experience and skills can I bring?
  • What are my key strengths, and where would I like to develop?
  • How have I handled challenges or contributed positively in previous roles?

My advice: Prepare your answers, but don’t memorise them word for word. Hiring managers want to get to know the person behind the CV, not hear a rehearsed script. AI tools can be useful for practising interview questions or researching an employer, but your answers should always reflect your genuine experience and personality.

 

First impressions still matter

It’s not just what you say during an interview, but how you communicate it.

Arriving on time, presenting yourself professionally and showing genuine enthusiasm can all contribute to a positive first impression.

I generally recommend arriving around 10 minutes early for an in-person interview. If you’re interviewing online, check your technology beforehand and find a quiet space where you won’t be interrupted.

During the conversation:

  • Listen carefully and provide clear, relevant answers.
  • Support your responses with real examples rather than simple “yes” or “no” answers.
  • Don’t be afraid to ask for clarification if a question isn’t clear.
  • Maintain natural eye contact, positive body language and a friendly manner.
  • Take your time when answering questions, particularly if you’re feeling nervous.

My advice: Remember that an interview should feel like a conversation, not an interrogation.

 

Show your value through real examples

Your CV has already helped you secure the interview. Now it’s your opportunity to bring your experience to life.

Hiring managers often meet candidates with similar qualifications and professional backgrounds. What can set you apart is your ability to explain how you’ve contributed to previous workplaces.

For example, if you’re a Bookkeeper, you might discuss how you’ve improved a financial process, managed competing deadlines or supported clients through a challenging situation.

For Administration or Client Services professionals, examples might include managing client relationships, improving office efficiency or supporting a busy team.

Try to explain the situation, what you did and the outcome you achieved. Don’t just tell the interviewer you’re organised, adaptable or a strong communicator. Give them an example that demonstrates it.

 

Build rapport and demonstrate cultural fit

This is something I’ve consistently observed when speaking with hiring managers, particularly within accounting practices.

The candidates who receive job offers aren’t always those with the most experience on paper. Often, it’s the candidates who build genuine rapport and demonstrate that they’ll work well within the team.

Technical skills are important, but so is finding someone whose working style, attitude and values align with the firm’s culture.

During your interview, be yourself. Show an interest in the people you’re meeting, listen actively and engage naturally in the conversation.

Think about what you enjoy in a workplace, how you collaborate with others and the type of environment where you do your best work. And remember, cultural fit works both ways. You should also feel comfortable that the organisation and its people are right for you.

 

Be thoughtful about salary and flexibility conversations

Salary expectations and flexible working arrangements are important considerations when exploring a new role. However, when and how you raise these topics can influence the impression you make.

One mistake I occasionally see is candidates introducing salary expectations during an interview, particularly when they’re seeking the very top of the advertised range without the experience to support it.

Ideally, salary expectations should be discussed with your recruiter before the interview so that both parties have a clear understanding of what’s realistic.

Similarly, while working from home is an important consideration for many candidates, I’d encourage you to understand the firm’s expectations and approach to flexibility before focusing on arrangements from day one.

There’s nothing wrong with asking about salary or flexible working. These are important factors in making the right career decision. It’s simply about approaching the conversation thoughtfully and at the appropriate stage.

If you’re working with a recruiter, use their knowledge to clarify these details before meeting the employer.

 

Ask questions that show genuine interest

An interview isn’t just an opportunity for the employer to assess you. It’s also your chance to decide whether the role is the right next step in your career.

Hiring managers generally appreciate candidates who come prepared with thoughtful questions.

Consider asking:

  • What does success look like in this role during the first six months?
  • How would you describe the team culture?
  • What are the biggest priorities or challenges for the person joining?
  • What opportunities are available for professional development?
  • How does the team collaborate and support one another?

My advice: Bringing a few written questions is perfectly acceptable. It shows you’ve taken the time to prepare and are genuinely interested in the opportunity.

 

Final advice: Be prepared, but be yourself

If there’s one thing I’ve learnt over more than two decades in recruitment, it’s that a successful interview is about more than ticking boxes on a job description.

Your CV tells an employer about your experience, but the interview is where they discover who you are, how you communicate and whether they can see you becoming part of their team.

Put yourself in the interviewer’s shoes. What would give you confidence that you’ve found the right person?

Prepare thoroughly, communicate honestly, show genuine interest and allow your personality to come through. And remember, the right opportunity should be a good fit for both you and the employer.

For more on this topic, read our article on how to tell if a job interview went well.  

If you would like more coaching on how to prepare yourself for an interview, please feel free to reach out to me on 0477 013 709 or email me at jenny@lawsondelaney.com.au. 

At Lawson Delaney, we work closely with accounting professionals and public practice firms across Melbourne. Feel free to check our current opportunities or contact our specialist recruitment team for help.

 

 


 

 

Frequently asked questions about job interviews

 

How can I make a good impression in a job interview?

Research the employer, arrive on time, listen carefully and give clear answers supported by genuine examples. A friendly, professional conversation can help the interviewer understand how you would work with the team.

 

What do hiring managers look for beyond experience?

Relevant skills matter, but hiring managers also consider communication, attitude, rapport and whether your working style aligns with the team. In accounting practices, Jenny regularly hears how important these factors are when employers make hiring decisions.

 

How should I answer interview questions if I feel nervous?

Take a moment to think, ask for clarification when needed and use a specific example from your experience. You can briefly explain the situation, what you did and the result. Aim to sound natural rather than reciting a memorised answer.

 

Should I discuss salary expectations during an interview?

It is reasonable to discuss remuneration, but ideally you and your recruiter will have clarified expectations before the interview. If salary comes up, explain your expectations realistically in relation to your experience and the role.

 

Is it okay to ask about working from home in an interview?

Yes. Flexible working is an important part of assessing an opportunity. Try to understand the firm’s existing arrangements and the role’s requirements first, then ask about expectations and whether flexibility is available from commencement.

 

How can I use AI to prepare for an interview?

AI can help you practise questions, organise examples and research topics to explore. Check any information it provides and use your own words and genuine experience in the interview.

 

ld-favicon
Published on November 12, 2026
Written by Jenny Ennis

Insights from the team

How to prepare for a job interview: Advice from an experienced recruiter

After more than 20 years working in recruitment, I’ve had countless conversations with hiring managers about what makes a successful…

How accountants can stay relevant in the age of AI

Artificial intelligence is changing the accounting profession, but does that mean experienced accountants should be concerned about their future? While…

How to manage multiple job interviews and offers

Receiving interest from several employers at once can be an exciting stage of your job search. But when interviews overlap,…

2026 Predictions in Public Practice Accounting

2025 has been another very busy and successful year for Public Practice Accounting firms, and from conversations with our many…

Beyond the Base Salary: Why Executive Search Success Starts with Remuneration Benchmarking

The stakes are high In the ultra-competitive executive market, a poorly structured remuneration package can lead to a rejected offer…

The Benefits of Part-Time Workers – For Employers and Job Seekers

In today’s evolving workforce, hiring part-time employees can offer significant advantages for both employers and job seekers. While many roles…

Why Job Searching Whilst Employed Is a Smart Career Move

Looking for a new job while you’re still employed is widely recognised as one of the most effective strategies for…

Toxic positivity in the Workplace

Toxic positivity in the workplace occurs when an organisation consistently downplays or dismisses valid concerns in favour of forced optimism….

Most Common Workplace Stressors in Australia Have One Simple Solution

Work-related stress can affect anyone, and in Australia, several common factors are known to contribute to burnout, anxiety, and reduced…

What It’s Really Like Working in Australia vs Overseas

Australia continues to attract qualified accounting professionals from around the world, offering the chance to build international experience while enjoying…

Accounting Firm Salary Guide 2025

Partner to Junior Accountant Salaries and more The Lawson Delaney Accounting Firm Salary Guide 2025 provides data by seniority, as well as…

The impact of a pay rise on your employer

Every week, I listen to candidates say they want a pay rise and not have a clue where the money…